Da' Matteo Ristorante Pizzeria

If you're searching for an unforgettable Italian dining experience on the Emerald Coast, look no further than Da' Matteo Ristorante Pizzeria in Mary Esther. This hidden gem blew us away with its authentic flavors, warm ambiance, and absolutely impeccable service. Every single dish we had was not only made from scratch but bursting with that rich, comforting authenticity that only true Italian cooking delivers. We started our meal with fresh bruschetta and warm house-made bread, both served with a drizzle of olive oil and love. The bruschetta was perfectly balanced — the tomatoes were vibrant and sweet, the basil fresh and aromatic, and the toasted bread had just the right crunch. The bread? Pillowy, warm, and so fresh you could taste the craftsmanship in every bite. Then came the main course — and oh, mamma mia, did it deliver! The chicken parmesan was a masterpiece: tender, juicy, lightly breaded chicken, smothered in a rich, house-made marinara and bubbling mozzarella that melted in our mouths. The spaghetti and meatballs were equally divine — the pasta cooked to a perfect al dente, the sauce deeply flavorful, and the meatballs... absolutely legendary. You could tell they were hand-rolled with care and seasoned to perfection. For the kids (and let's be honest, the adults too), we ordered the heart-shaped pepperoni pizza — a fun and charming touch that won us over instantly. But beyond the cute presentation, the pizza itself was incredible: crisp-yet-chewy crust, just the right amount of char, rich tomato sauce, and generous pepperoni layered with love. And just when we thought the meal couldn’t get better — the tiramisu arrived. Creamy, luxurious, with the perfect coffee kick and that melt-in-your-mouth texture that only a true Italian kitchen can achieve. It was the ultimate finale to an already perfect dining experience. Every single bite at Da' Matteo tasted like it was prepared with passion and tradition. The quality, the authenticity, and the attention to detail were astounding. It felt like stepping into a cozy trattoria in Italy — without ever leaving Florida. This place is the real deal, and we can’t wait to return. Bravo, Da' Matteo. You’ve won our hearts — and our taste buds — forever.

Don't let the simple exterior fool you! The authentic Italian food here is unbeatable! When we visit Navarre, this place is on our list of "must-haves"! The food is fresh and made to order. They have a simple wine list and a full bar. The Gnocchi Formaggi is my absolute favorite, and my daughter loves the lasagna! You can dress up or come in your flips!

Came here on a whim with my folks, came back the next day with my wife! This is a Fantastic place for “real Italian” food at a NW Florida vibe. The imported brick oven makes the best tasting pizza and calzones. Instead of passin by, make the turn and enjoy!

We love this local Italian restaurant. Service is great! Food delicious! Today we enjoyed the sole mio pizza. Delicious! We ordered the calamari and the marinara sauce served with it is so so good! Also enjoyed a full bodied, aromatic, flavorful glass of Chianti. Bravo!

I started eating here back in February this year. My mother’s family is from Napoli, and eating here is exactly like being in Napoli again. I’ve never been disappointed. The pizza is incredible, but so are the appetizers and the homemade pasta and sauce. The burrata and bruschetta alone make me smile. It’s a true, authentic family restaurant and an absolute treasure to have in our area.

The chicken parm and pasta were delicious. My wife had the lasagna and said it was outstanding also.

Took a chance on this road side pizza place . Was surprised. Great wood fire pizza . Casual enough but service of a “fancier” type restaurant. Our waiter was very attentive. Food was yummy. Don’t skip the cannoli. 130 for a family of 9 plus tip.

Came with my family and we are all in love with the place. Authentic Italian pizza and pasta. Amazing service and atmosphere. Recommended 100%